We looked at the 'real' origin story behind Thanksgiving and why many Native Americans don't like it and don't observe it. Thanksgiving, as commonly celebrated in the United States today, is often associated with the Pilgrims' feast in Plymouth, Massachusetts, in 1621. However, the history of Thanksgiving has been muddled, debunked, and rewritten throughout history.
For centuries, Thanksgiving has been billed as an opportunity for friends and family to gather, with peace and gratitude in their hearts. It is a time to appreciate the abundance of the harvest and to give thanks for the blessings in one's life. But what inspired the Pilgrims to hold the first Thanksgiving in America?
The Pilgrims, a group of English settlers seeking religious freedom, arrived in Plymouth in 1620. They faced numerous challenges, including harsh weather, disease, and food scarcity. With the help of Native Americans, particularly the Wampanoag tribe, the Pilgrims learned survival skills and cultivated crops. Their first successful harvest led to a three-day feast, which is often identified as the first Thanksgiving.
The Pilgrims were thankful for the assistance and friendship of the Native Americans, who played a crucial role in their survival. They were grateful for the bountiful harvest, which ensured their sustenance during the upcoming winter months. Additionally, the Pilgrims expressed gratitude for the opportunity to practice their religion freely in the New World.
However, it is important to acknowledge the perspective of Native Americans regarding Thanksgiving. The Indigenous community members who live in the United States tell a much different story about Thanksgiving. They view it as a reminder of the painful history of colonization, displacement, and genocide that followed the arrival of European settlers.
Many Native American tribes do not celebrate Thanksgiving or observe it in the same way as the majority of Americans. For them, it is a time to mourn the loss of their ancestral lands and the devastating consequences of colonization. It is a time to honor their ancestors and raise awareness about the ongoing struggles faced by Indigenous communities.
The complex and often conflicting narratives surrounding Thanksgiving highlight the need for reflection and reconciliation. As a nation, we must confront our history and acknowledge the injustices committed against Native Americans. This includes listening to their stories, amplifying their voices, and working towards a more inclusive and equitable future.
While the traditions and symbols associated with Thanksgiving may hold different meanings for various individuals and communities, it is crucial to approach the holiday with empathy and understanding. Thanksgiving can serve as an opportunity to foster dialogue, educate ourselves about Indigenous cultures, and support Native American initiatives.
Modern Thanksgiving celebrations are marked by warm gatherings with loved ones (family- or Friendsgiving-style), autumn-themed foods, and expressions of gratitude. It is a time to reflect on the blessings in our lives and show appreciation for the relationships and experiences that enrich us.
As we commemorate the 400th anniversary of the Pilgrims' arrival, it is an occasion to remember the complex history that led to the first Thanksgiving. It is a chance to honor the contributions of Native Americans and strive for a more inclusive society. By embracing the true spirit of Thanksgiving—compassion, empathy, and reconciliation—we can create a meaningful holiday that unites rather than divides.
